Glenn Kessler, the fact-checking columnist of the Washington Post, often employs logic that's more factually dubious than the claim he's covering.

Here's his explanation for why he gives President Obama four Pinocchios for saying in ads that Mitt Romney wants to kill Big Bird:

Romney may have been off base in suggesting PBS funding has much to do with the deficit, but that's no excuse for the Obama campaign to declare that means the demise of a popular children's character. According to the financials of Sesame Workshop, Big Bird should do just fine, with or without public funding.

Romney said during the debate he wants to kill funding for PBS, citing Big Bird and Jim Lehrer as examples of its programming.

PBS receives 15 percent of its funding from the federal government, which amounts to around $1 per American per year. But some of its member stations are not funded as well as others, as PBS explains:

These dollars are particularly important to smaller stations. While the appropriation equals about 15 percent of our system's revenue, this is an aggregate number. For many stations, the appropriation counts for as much as 40-50 percent of their budget.

If Romney becomes president and eliminates funding to PBS, some of its stations will lose half of their funding overnight and almost certainly shut down. For those viewers, this will kill Big Bird and all the rest of the programming that public television provides.

The issue isn't whether Sesame Street could survive without PBS. It would, because the show has 43 years of popularity and generates millions in licensing revenue. The issue is whether PBS stations could survive without federal funding.

The Obama ads are using Big Bird as a metaphor for the programming that would disappear from the homes of Americans if Romney killed PBS funding. I think it's a fair use of rhetoric that doesn't deserve to be called a lie.

-- Rogers Cadenhead

Comments

If just 10% of taxpayers started/increased giving just $1.25/month (just $15/year), they would more than make up the money we're talking about. If they can't get $15/year from 10% of Americans, we probably shouldn't be getting federal dollars.


 

Would you apply that rule to defense spending? If just 10 percent of Americans gave $22,470 a year, that would fund our nation's military.

I think $1 a year is worth it when it provides educational benefits to children and cultural and informational benefits to the public.


 

I wish I had a good platform for an idea I've had for an article about where "fact-checking" went wrong. Essentially, US journalistic rules which stress form over substance are being applied to questions of deep substance, and hence giving perverse results. That is, US journalistic rules are that you can wildly misconstrue someone's intent, change the phrasing of what they said or take it out of context to imply something else, and that's all OK - but you'd better spell the names right, otherwise that's wrong. It's heavily literal in that specific sense. That shows up in what you say right here (my emphasis) - "The Obama ads are using Big Bird as a metaphor for the programming ...". That metaphor is the problem. Romney doesn't literally want to end Sesame Street, so in that narrow sense, he doesn't want to kill Big Bird. Whether defunding PBS stations can fairly be described as killing Big Bird is very much a judgment that requires a bunch of associated concepts. And making those sort of determinations is a much harder task, one that US journalist rules are ill-equipped to handle philosophically.


 

I think the question is whether the US government should be involved in spending taxpayers money on funding for PBS. Personally, I don't think its the governments place to be funding PBS. I the American public wants this avenue of education for their children, let them fund it themselves, individually. This is the problem with the government and their runaway spending. Everybody wants to fund all these feel good projects instead of what the government was established to do.


 

... making those sort of determinations is a much harder task, one that US journalist rules are ill-equipped to handle philosophically.

I don't know why it has to be so hard. Why can't fact checkers like Kessler confine themselves to factual matters that can be determined with more certainty? The question of whether "kill Big Bird" should be taken literally or metaphorically requires more nuance than to declare it a lie or the truth.


 

The problem is that "kill Big Bird" is, structurally, not significantly different from "kill Medicare [as we know it]". If a fact-checker can't handle "kill Medicare", then they are severely circumscribed in the role they can play. They're essentially constrained to checking if the names are spelled right - i.e. almost anything that really matters, they can't handle.


 

The action "kill Big Bird" is obviously not literal, so it lends itself to being interpreted as a metaphor.

The action "kill Medicare" could be literal, because a government program can be killed.

I'd prefer that fact checkers like Kessler focus on political statements and ads that should be interpreted literally. An evaluation of whether Paul Ryan wants to kill Medicare by replacing it with vouchers for people 55 and under is sophisticated, but not impossible.


 

Great looking internet site. Presume you did a great deal of your very own coding.
billige fotballdrakter www.travelstobhutan.com


 

Maintain the helpful work and generating the group!


 

Wow cuz this is very great work! Congrats and keep it up.


 

Love the website-- very user pleasant and lots to see!
maglie calcio a poco prezzo www.synchronizationofus.com


 

Hi, great website you've going here.
billige fotballdrakter www.nottheitgirls.com


 

Amazing Webpage, Continue the good work. Thanks for your time.|


 

thank a lot for your site it helps a lot.
fotbollstr?jor www.tampabaygoodliving.com


 

You're a very practical website; couldn't make it without ya!
billige fodboldtr?jer www.zamanthajoeh.com


 

Great web site! It looks extremely expert! Maintain the good work!
magliette calcio www.doralcentermall.com


 

Maintain the amazing job !! Lovin' it!


 

Thanks for giving like good knowledge.


 

Wow cuz this is excellent work! Congrats and keep it up.


 

The information is incredibly appealing.


 

I like this website - its so usefull and helpfull.
PSG Drakt www.socalhardwoodflooring.com


 

You have remarkable information in this case.


 

What's happening, neat website you have got at this time there.
Chelsea Tr?jer www.shannonmdrealty.com


 

Maintain the incredible job !! Lovin' it!


 

You've gotten incredible info in this article.


 

You're an extremely practical site; could not make it without ya!
Maglia Valencia Poco Prezzo www.zeropartypolitics.com


 

Very good site you possess here.
Fotbollstr?jor www.bettermensolutions.com<>


 

good night
good morning
happy birthday
good night
good night
good night
good night
good night
good night
good night
good night
good night
good night
good night
good night
good night
good night
good night
good night
good night
good night
good night
good night
good night
good night
good night
good night
good night
good night
good night
good night
good night
good night
good night
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
Good night Messages
Good night Messages
Good night Messages
Good night Messages
Good night Messages
Good night Messages
Good night Messages
Good night Messages
Good night Messages
Good night Messages
Good night Messages
Good night quotes
Good night quotes
Good night quotes
Good night quotes
Good night quotes
Good night quotes
Good night quotes
Good night quotes
Good night quotes
Good night quotes
Good night quotes
Good night quotes
Good night quotes
Good night quotes
Good night wishes
Good night wishes
Good night wishes
Good night wishes
Good night wishes
Good night wishes
Good night wishes
Good night wishes
Good night wishes
Good night wishes
Good night wishes
Good night wishes
Good night wishes
Good night wishes
Good night wishes
Good night wishes
Good night wishes
Good night wishes
Good night wishes
Good night wishes
Good night wishes
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari/a>
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
best whatsapp status
best whatsapp status
best whatsapp status
best whatsapp status
best whatsapp status
best whatsapp status
best whatsapp status
best whatsapp status
best whatsapp status
best whatsapp status
best whatsapp status
best whatsapp status
best whatsapp status
best whatsapp status
best whatsapp status
Diwali Messages
Diwali Messages
Diwali Messages
Diwali Messages
Diwali Messages
Diwali Messages
Diwali Messages
Diwali Messages
Diwali Messages
Diwali Messages
Diwali Messages
Diwali Messages
Diwali Messages
Diwali Messages
Diwali Messages
good night messages for girlfriend
good night messages for girlfriend
good night messages for girlfriend
good night messages for girlfriend
good night messages for girlfriend
good night messages for girlfriend
good night messages for girlfriend
good night messages for girlfriend
good night messages for girlfriend
good night messages for girlfriend
good night messages for girlfriend
good night messages for girlfriend
good night messages for girlfriend
good night messages for girlfriend
good night messages for girlfriend
good night messages for girlfriend
good night messages for girlfriend
Night Text Messages For Her
Night Text Messages For Her
Night Text Messages For Her
Night Text Messages For Her
Night Text Messages For Her
Night Text Messages For Her

Good Night Girlfriend Collection
Good Night Girlfriend Collection
Good Night Girlfriend Collection
Good Night Girlfriend Collection
Good Night Girlfriend Collection
Good Night Girlfriend Collection
Good Night Girlfriend Collection
Good Night Girlfriend Collection
Good Night Girlfriend Collection
Good Night Girlfriend Collection
Good Night Girlfriend Collection
Good Night Girlfriend Collection
Good Night Girlfriend Collection
Good Night Girlfriend Collection
Good Night Girlfriend Collection
Good Night Messages For Her
Good Night Messages For Her
Good Night Messages For Her
Good Night Messages For Her
Good Night Messages For Her
Good Night Messages For Her
Good Night Messages For Her
Good Night Messages For Her
Good Night Messages For Her
Good Night Messages For Her
Good Night Messages For Her
Good Night Messages For Her
Good Night Messages For Her
Good Night Messages For Her
Good Night Messages For Her
Good Night Messages For Her
Whatsapp Status | Romantic And Sad
Whatsapp Status | Romantic And Sad
Whatsapp Status | Romantic And Sad
Whatsapp Status | Romantic And Sad
Whatsapp Status | Romantic And Sad
Whatsapp Status | Romantic And Sad
Whatsapp Status | Romantic And Sad
Whatsapp Status | Romantic And Sad
Whatsapp Status | Romantic And Sad
Whatsapp Status | Romantic And Sad
Whatsapp Status | Romantic And Sad
Whatsapp Status | Romantic And Sad
Whatsapp Status | Romantic And Sad
Whatsapp Status | Romantic And Sad
Whatsapp Status | Romantic And Sad
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari

Very usefull article thanks ... keep writing such articles :)
I'm so happy bcoz you are write this post for everyone thnxx a lot

Good night messages for girlfriend

Good Morning messages for girlfriend

Good night love SMS | Romantic Night SMS

Rohit sharma Accountant | Blogger

Good Night Messages For Her

Girlfriend Impress Images and Wallpapaer

I love u messages for girlfriend

Good Night Messages for mother

Good Night Images HD Wallpaper

Happy Diwali Wishes For Girlfriend

Diwali Wishes 2018

Good night messages wishes and quotes

Raksha Bandhan Wishes For Sister *Raksha Bandhan Wishes*

#50 Sweet Good Night Messages For Wife: Romantic Night Quotes For Wife

#50 *Girlfriend Propose Messages* Heart Touching

Good Morning Messages For Wife

Good Morning Messages For Friends

Happy New Year Wishes 2019: Best New Year Messages

I love u Messages for wife

i love u messages for dad

i love u messages for son

i love u messages for mother

good night messages for uncle and aunt

good night images for girlfriend

good night images for whatsapp and facebook

good night quotes messages , wishes, for husband

Good Morning Messages For Friends

Raksha Bandhan Images Brother and Sister

Love Shayari -Love Romantic Shayari

Best Whatsapp Status

Love Attitude Status For Girls & Boys


 

Add a Comment

These HTML tags are permitted: p, b, i, a, and blockquote. A comment may not include more than three links. Participants in this discussion should note the site's moderation policy.