Bit.ly logoThe URL shortening service Bit.ly just secured $2 million in financing from investors including O'Reilly's AlphaTech Ventures. Though URL shorteners have been around for years, Bit.ly believes there's money in offering Twitter-friendly short links along with web analytics to track how the links are used. The company reports that its links were clicked 20 million times last month.

So far, the news coverage I've read about Bit.ly has neglected an unusual aspect of the startup: It's one of the only prominent online ventures using a domain name in the .LY namespace, which is controlled by Libya.

There are two issues that arise from this relationship.

First, of course, is the appearance of an American company doing business with Libya, a country that the U.S. considered a state sponsor of terror from 1979 through 2006. On Dec. 21, 1988, Libyan intelligence agents planted a bomb on Pan Am Flight 103 that blew up 31,000 feet over Lockerbie, Scotland, killing all 259 people onboard.

Bit.ly's only doing a trivial amount of business with Libya -- the domains sell for $75 per year from the registrar Libyan Spider Network -- but its use of .LY domain is helping to popularize and legitimize the top-level domain for general use on the Internet. It's only a matter of time before a reporter decides to ask the families of Lockerbie victims what they think of the arrangement. I can't imagine that story going well for the company.

Even without that PR hit, there's another potential concern for Bit.ly and any other venture that builds its business on an .LY domain. These domains are governed by Libyan law, as it states on the Libyan Spider Network site:

Any .LY domain names may be registered, except domains containing obscene and indecent names/phrases, including words of a sexual nature; furthermore domain names may not contain words/phrases or abbreviations insulting religion or politics, or be related to gambling and lottery industry or be contrary to Libyan law or Islamic morality.

So the names must conform to Islamic morality, and it's possible that the use of the domains could fall under the same rules. What are the odds that some of those 20 million clicks on a Bit.ly-shortened URL end up at sites that would be considered blasphemous or otherwise offensive in an Islamic nation? Bit.ly conveniently provides search pages for such topics as Islam, sharia, gambling and sex, any of which contain links that could spark another controversy.

Bit.ly's building a business atop a domain that could be taken away at any time, and the company's only recourse would be to seek redress in the Libyan court system. Take a look at Section 11 of the regulations for .LY owners:

The Arabic language is the language of interpretation, correspondence and the construction of the Regulation or anything related to it. ... In case of conflict between the Arabic and the English versions the Arabic version shall prevail.

I hope Bit.ly's attorneys are brushing up on their Arabic.

-- Rogers Cadenhead

Comments

Nice. I just refuse to use Bit.ly because it's run by people who don't give a rat's ass about the wishes of web authors -- it aggressively caches the content of all URLs that people use the service to shorten, even if the sites contain headers specifically asking NOT to be cached.

q.queso.com

When I questioned them about this, they gave lipservice to fixing it, but then never did; when I then filed a takedown request for content they're caching from my site, they threatened lawsuit.

Assholes.


 

Cool. I will start using bit.ly for all my dirty porn link shortening needs.


 

I'm surprised that Bit.ly thinks it can get away with disregarding cache instructions and not fixing the problem after saying that it would. Given its business, you'd think the company would realize how quickly bad PR can travel over blogs and Twitter.


 

3rd party URL shorteners: old and busted.


Self-hosted short URLs: new hotness.


 

I would suggest we leave the past in the history. British were killing Americans, Spanish - Mexicans, etc - etc. Neither .UK, nor .ES, neither .LY domains and other Internet projects have nothing to do to those days horrors.

I have seen many Italians using .ly domains, all good projects, e.g., bright.ly, fami.ly, sil.ly, serious.ly...

.ly domains are fun, the more - the merrier. As to porn: I would real.ly love to see it all locked under .xxx - so parents all over the world would not worry about perverts targeting kids trying to learn useful stuff on the web.


 

I have seen many great .LY sites, bit.ly is not the best, but it may prevail. There are so many URL shorteners...

What I real.ly love is song.ly.

Check out more great .LY names.


 

Apparently, there is a way to use bit.ly and avoid the .ly

twitter.com


 

I was curious this morning (well, this very early morning) to know more about the .ly TLD domain, and now I know. I think this whole decision (for choosing this TLD) can put millions (if not billions already) of links in jeopardy. I don't understand why twitter made the decision to favor bit.ly over all the other given the volatile nature of the domain. I think it's better to stick with .us / .ca domains for country TLDs, they are the safest and the maturest.


 

Libyan agents didn't blow up the Lockerbie flight. At least that's what investigators originally claimed, and had a very strong case for this.

It was in fact Iranian agents retaliating to the shooting down of an Iranian civilian airliner by a U.S. ship, which had also trespassed into Iranian waters. But this is rarely mentioned...

Some more info here for example:
covertaction.org


 

We've added an article based on this post and the others that have reported this earlier. My post about how webmasters feel about "rogue country" domains, is at blog.WebByFred.com<>


 

Your conclusion that links may contain immoral phrases/words/etc. due to Islamic law, is flat out wrong, as it's the domain itself that must conform, not any links on the domain. Your other concerns are valid, however, a spurious claim like this diminishes the value of them.


 

Your words turned out prescient but not for the domain you specifically pointed out. In August of '09 I sent an email to Violet Blue with a link to your article because she was promoting "the internet's first and only sex-positive URL shortener". She sent a nice reply and I thought nothing much of it until recently when I went looking for vb.ly and couldn't find it. I did find this:

news.cnet.com


 

Forget bit.ly? Have you already tried brief.ly? You can combine many links in one go. Super easy, super convenient.


 

We have used Bit.ly's services when we first started out sharing messages on Twitter.

Like most county code domains, one may not know *where* in the world that is and probably fewer still take the time to investigate it. I know we didn't. It's much like those software agreements -- as if you really have any other choice but to use the program.

Fortunately, there are alternatives to Bit.ly and unless you're doing things that you shouldn't show grandma, then one should really be using these other methods for long-term link growth.

For example, use a 301 redirect in your .htaccess file so you can control the domain and link life duration.

What would happen if Bit.ly decided to delete all of your shortened URLs? They haven't promised to keep them for life you know.

If you're in the marketing arena, or even if you're merely sharing photos on Facebook, your URLs will no longer work.

Something to think about, as with most *free* services on the 'net.


 

Thanks regarding delivering this sort of good written content.


 

Appreciate it for sharing your nice site.
fotballdrakter barn www.travelstobhutan.com


 

Keep up the exceptional job !! Lovin' it!


 

I enjoy this website - its so usefull and helpfull.
fotballdrakter barn www.travelstobhutan.com


 

Great looking website. Presume you did a great deal of your very own html coding.
billige fodboldtr?jer www.crimsontee.com


 

Merely wished to express I'm happy I happened in your page!|


 

Terrific internet site you've got going here.
magliette calcio a poco prezzo www.synchronizationofus.com


 

Thank you! It is an astounding web site!
fotballdrakter barn www.travelstobhutan.com


 

Wow cuz this is excellent work! Congrats and keep it up.


 

Thanks for supplying these superior content material.


 

Simply just desired to emphasize I am just ecstatic I stumbled on the website page!|


 

Passion the website-- extremely user friendly and great deals to see!
ajax tr?ja www.afterglowvp.com


 

Amazing....such a handy website.
fotbollstr?ja www.afterglowvp.com


 

You've great thing at this point.


 

You have got the most impressive web sites.
magliette calcio www.glivytech.com


 

Hello there, good website you have going here.
magliette calcio www.glivytech.com


 

Thanks, this site is extremely useful.
maglie calcio a poco prezzo www.glivytech.com


 

Thanks with regard to supplying these kinds of good data.


 

Highly instructive, look forth to coming back.


 

Great internet website! It looks extremely expert! Keep up the helpful work!
fotbollstr?jor med eget tryck www.tampabaygoodliving.com


 

You have got among the best online sites.
billige fodboldtr?jer www.zamanthajoeh.com


 

You're a really practical website; could not make it without ya!
fodboldtr?jer b?rn www.zamanthajoeh.com


 

I enjoy the info on your website. thnx.
fotbollstr?jor barn www.tampabaygoodliving.com


 

Wow, lovely website. Thnx ...
fodboldtr?jer www.zamanthajoeh.com


 

Many thanks, this site is very helpful.
fotbollstr?jor www.tampabaygoodliving.com


 

Thanks very handy. Will share site with my friends.
maglie calcio poco prezzo www.doralcentermall.com


 

You have the best internet websites.
Maglie Calcio a poco prezzo www.niveauradio.com


 

I enjoy browsing your web sites. Thanks for your time!
Maglie Calcio a poco prezzo www.niveauradio.com


 

Incredibly user pleasant website. Immense info offered on few clicks.
Maglie Calcio a poco prezzo www.niveauradio.com


 

Keep up the excellent work and generating the group!


 

Amazing site you've there.
maglie del calcio www.doralcentermall.com


 

The information is amazingly appealing.


 

Unbelievably user pleasant website. Tremendous info readily available on couple of clicks on.
Magliette Calcio Poco Prezzo www.wendtsporkpalace.com


 

Thanks extremely valuable. Will share website with my good friends.
maglie calcio www.haeroo.com


 

Amazing such a important website.
Magliette Calcio Poco Prezzo www.wendtsporkpalace.com


 

Very good content you have here.


 

I love perusing your site. With thanks!
maglie calcio www.haeroo.com


 

Great looking web site. Think you did a great deal of your very own html coding.
fodboldtr?jer b?rn www.shannonmdrealty.com


 

Wow, lovely portal. Thnx ...


 

Wow, attractive website. Thnx ...
Barcelona Tr?jor www.fashionradicalsnews.com


 

Appreciate it! It is an terrific website!
fotbolldrakter www.socalhardwoodflooring.com<>


 

Great internet website! It looks really good! Sustain the great job!
Napoli Drakt www.socalhardwoodflooring.com


 

Incredibly individual friendly site. Tremendous details readily available on couple of gos to.
PSG Drakt www.socalhardwoodflooring.com


 

Unbelievably user pleasant website. Immense information offered on few gos to.
Maglia Juventus Poco Prezzo www.theconservatarianreview.com


 

You have got the most effective web pages.
Maglia Everton Poco Prezzo www.theconservatarianreview.com


 

You have got terrific info on this site.
Maglia Juventus Poco Prezzo www.theconservatarianreview.com


 

The stuff is amazingly important.


 

I appreciate the information on your web sites. Thanks a bunch.
Arsenal Tr?jer www.shannonmdrealty.com


 

You have among the finest websites.
Chelsea Tr?jor www.fashionradicalsnews.com


 

I like this site - its so usefull and helpfull.
Manchester United Tr?jor www.bettermensolutions.com


 

Regards for sharing this well put together webpage.
Maglia PSG Poco Prezzo www.zeropartypolitics.com


 

Simply just needed to say Now i'm thankful I happened on your page!|


 

Very enlightening look forth to coming back again.


 

Great looking internet site. Assume you did a bunch of your very own html coding.
Liverpool Tr?jer www.asleftasfound.com


 

You've remarkable information in this article.


 

Hi-ya, excellent webpage you have here.
Maglia Atletico Madrid Poco Prezzo www.zeropartypolitics.com


 

Many thanks really beneficial. Will share site with my good friends.
Napoli Tr?jer www.asleftasfound.com


 

Seriously....this is a valuable online site.
Napoli Drakt www.mydescubrimientos.com


 

Simply want to say I am happy I happened onto your site.|


 

Many thanks, this site is really useful.
Manchester City Drakt www.mydescubrimientos.com


 

Nice web site you've got in here.
Barcelona Tr?jor www.bettermensolutions.com


 

Thank you for sharing your cool web-site.
fotbollströjor barn www.programdersleri.com


 

Add a Comment

These HTML tags are permitted: p, b, i, a, and blockquote. A comment may not include more than three links. Participants in this discussion should note the site's moderation policy.