\n

I've accepted an invitation to join the RSS 2.0 Advisory Board, the group that evangelizes the RSS 2.0 specification.

Contrary to what you may have read elsewhere, RSS 2.0 isn't owned or controlled by vendors. The specification has been released under a Creative Commons license and the format it represents has no trademark or copyright claims. My new job has very little actual power associated with it, sadly enough, and only one groupie.

The Advisory Board's primary task is explaining why the format has been successful and how new publishers can adopt it.

Recently on a mailing list, a longtime Web geek who I respect stated that RSS was "a crufty kludge that must evolve or die."

Even if it never changed again, the RSS 2.0 format would continue to fill an important role as the simplest XML syndication format for Web sites.

On technical grounds, there's nothing that requires the format to change or be replaced. It's valid XML supported by hundreds of programs for thousands of users. None of Mark Pilgrim's lovingly documented quirks has prevented it from becoming one of the most popular XML formats on the planet.

Additionally, the simplicity of RSS 2.0 helps sell syndication, because many Web publishers who look at an RSS file decide it's easy to implement.

Compare that to Pilgrim's Atom feed. Would anyone be doing this today if that was the first approach to syndication?

Atom has found a significant audience thanks to Six Apart and Google and may take XML Web publishing into new areas, so I'm not knocking the effort.

However, we've reached critical mass with RSS, which creates opportunities for new sites, Web services, and businesses. RSS has become so popular today that people are starting to make "imminent death" predictions about overloading the Internet.

Even if another format was so perfectly specified that it made grown computer scientists weep, it would be a crime to drop RSS now. That's why I made an empty threat to boycott Google last week in the New York Times; the "do no evil" crowd should offer its existing RSS support in Blogger rather than favoring one Internet protocol over another. The decision fails the if-Microsoft-did-it test big time.

At this point, you probably recognize why I was suggested for the board.

-- Rogers Cadenhead

Comments

Oh. I'm sorry. Never mind.


 

So who else was added? Or did someone leave? There's supposed to be an odd number, isn't there?

And congratulations :)


 

Speaking of the difficulties in the implementation of Atom, Google is offering Atom feeds for their Google Groups Beta. I know it *is* a beta, but I find it somewhat humorous that the feeds generated are not valid Atom (at least the one I tried.)

Here's an example feed

http://groups-beta.google.com/group/dripmail/feed/msgs.xml

And here's a link to the feed validator:

http://feeds.archive.org/validator/check.cgi?url=http%3A%2F%2Fgroups-beta.google.com%2Fgroup% 2Fdripmail%2Ffeed%2Fmsgs.xml

If Google can't even get the details right, what does that say about this format? (Or Google, but I'm not going to go there.)

Also, I don't all think the problems with the feed are minor, they reflect that some of the decisions made for the format are fundamentally flawed, which I wrote about on my site here: http://trenchant.org/dripmail/2004-05.html#224


 

Congratulations - better late than never :-) I was surprised you weren't on board from the start - from a perspective of skills and knowledge of RSS2.0.

"how new publishers can adopt it"
1.) Re-open the ssf-dev group - you were making quite a bit of progress there.
2.) A Best Practice document of implementing RSS2.0.
3.) A reference implementation of RSS and its APIs would help.

Good luck.


 

Congrats, Rogers, but this doesn't strike me as a surprise. What would have been a surprise is someone appointed who has been critical of the RSS 2.0 syndication feed, Dave Winer, or both.

So when is Andrew Grummett getting an appointment?




 

Sorry that's Grumet, not Grrrrummett.


 

Congrats! Hopefully you can bring a critical eye to RSS 2.0, and do something more constructive than FUDding the alternatives.

I can't really see a huge difference in the complexity of the RSS/Atom examples you point to - a few more attributes. The most notable being the ones which remove the ambiguity over escaping found in the RSS 2.0 spec. If anything, I'd have said the Atom listing is a little more newbie-friendly - no need to ask "what's a ?" and "what does describe?"


 

heh, the curse of escaping - that should have been: "what's a [guid]?" and "what does [description] describe?"


 

Thanks, everyone.

It's possible I'm basing too much on my personal experience, Danny. When I was learning XML, I found it a lot easier to understand XML dialects without namespaces or attributes.

As for appointing a critic of RSS 2.0 to the advisory board, it's a group of evangelists, so naturally the people who end up there are unabashed fans.


 

First I heard that advisory boards were the same as cheerleaders. I thought that the important component was bringing in a non-biased perspective, to ensure that the spec was open and reflected community opinion.

You just called it a group of evangelists. You realize that you just condemned the openness of this group? At least the professed supposed openness of this group?

Is Jon Udell an RSS evangelist? I'll have to send him email, ask him.


 

"Even if it never changed again, the RSS 2.0 format would continue to fill an important role as the simplest XML syndication format for Web sites."

Um, no. There's a reason some of us are still using RSS 0.9X until Atom becomes a bit more mature.

And all of your slams against Mark Pilgrim/Atom while announcing that you're joining the RSS board is just plain petty.


 

Where am I slamming him? I linked to his Atom feed because I figured he's likely to be doing Atom right (I don't know the format well enough to judge), and I discussed his "nine versions of RSS" piece because it's probably the most well-researched slam on RSS 0.9x/2.0 ever written.


 

I'd just like to nominate Shelley for the 2004 Prescience Award. Brent Simmons and Jon Udell have apparently chosen to leave the Advisory Board, and Andrew Grumet and Adam Curry are two out of the other three new members.


 

I'm judging the purpose of the RSS Advisory Board by the language on its Web site (emphasis mine):

"We answer questions, write tech notes, advocate for RSS, make minor changes to the spec per the roadmap, help people use the technology, send flowers to developers, maintain a directory of compatible applications, accept contributions from community members, and otherwise do what we can to help people and organizations be successful with RSS."

Though I wouldn't have problems with board members with less-than-glowing praise for RSS, I'm comfortable being on there as an evangelist.


 

Then it shouldn't be sold as a way for the community to have open communication in regards to the specification, or that this 'board' is somehow an alternative to an open standards based effort. As it has been promoted in the past, and still being promoted now.

I am not suprised at Udell's resignation form this so-called board. Or Grumet's appointment.

But I am surprised at how long I've maintained an RSS 2.0 feed for my weblogs. Must remedy that.



 

I don't think it's productive to respond to the sneer that we're a bunch of lackeys, Shelley. You'll just have to judge by our actions whether the four new board members are receptive to public opinion.


 

Bryant, thank you. I accept that award. Crystal ball readings next Saturday.

Thank you Dave.

Thank you Dave.

Thank you Dave.

The day this board makes a decision about RSS that runs counter to Dave Winer's own opinion and choice, is the day I'll reinstate my RSS 2.0 feed. How's that for giving the board a chance, Rogers?


 

Dan Gillmore: My first question was whether some people in those communities will assume that Simmons, having worked for Winer, will be a rubber stamp.


 

So Mark's calling the RSS board a "puppet government" and Sam's digging up a year-old link to make similar insinuations.

This is a shame. You're in a position to make Atom a W3C standard, which in my book is a hell of an accomplishment. Why are you denigrating someone else's attempt to make RSS 2.0 better? You've both said several times you wanted to escape the political climate of RSS. So go already. I'd like to start missing you as soon as possible.


 

Prove me wrong. Prove that you're not just a bunch of starry-eyed RSS sharecroppers. Jon and Brent worked very hard to try to provide some forward motion in the RSS community, and they found that no forward motion was possible without Dave's consent. (cf. Relative links, markup in titles, core namespace, acceptable use of other namespaces... this list goes on.)

Maybe you, Andrew, and Adam can do better, but I doubt it.


 

Will there ever be anyone on the RSS Advisory Board who

a.) Has no financial or historical tie to Userland or its products (i.e. a former employee, an investor, or someone who sells a book about the product)

and/or

b.) Is not a personal friend of Userland's current/former leadership?

I'm sure Userland's RSS-supporting competitors would be interested in a (serious) answer.


 

Rogers, actually, I was pointing at a weblog entry where Dan Gillmor described an early vote where Dave was in the minority.


 

Wow.

Coming to the comment party late, but here goes:

Rogers--congratulations. Any advisory board appointment is noteworthy, whether it's a local civic traffic board for a city council or one advocating the wider use of a syndication format.

All that are of the Atom/RSS fight brigade: Please go play somewhere else. Atom and RSS both have a place. Atom can be a higher end API and syndication format (and a dessert topping for those who remember SNL's early days) and RSS can be a simple syndication format.

I like to compare the two with the 2.4GHz spectrum. The FCC licensed it for experimental use and we got 802.11 wireless network connections (or RSS in my analogy). There still exist licensed microwave bands for people who need something else either more restrictive or more robust (Atom).

I like RSS for now. I might like Atom later. But lets not kill *either one* by running over them with a semi-truck full of hate and discontent.

Please? Is this all that intelligent people can do together is fight? Rogers has made great attempts in this thread to keep it civil--thanks.


 

I have hand coded XSL Transforms for both RSS 2.0, & Atom. I did not find Atom any more difficult than RSS to generate and I've learned to do this for both formats simply by reading their specs and looking at example feeds. Both of the feeds I generate validate easily. I am currently generating both since not all feed readers support Atom yet. I do like, that Atom clears up the problem of including html with in the content, where RSS official spec doesn't support that. Many feed readers do seem to support the xhtml:body element in RSS though.

I'll probably move to Atom alone because I like the way you can specify the format of the content with in the feed. IE text/html/xml ...


 

Great Article it its really informative and innovative keep us posted with new updates. its was really valuable. thanks a lot.
grill brus


 

Excellent article. Very interesting to read. I really love to read such a nice article. Thanks! keep rocking.
how to preform a website audit


 

The website is looking bit flashy and it catches the visitors eyes. Design is pretty simple and a good user friendly interface.
Stag Strippers


 

I think this is an informative post and it is very useful and knowledgeable. therefore. I would like to thank you for the efforts you have made in writing this article.
https://www.donerightdemo.com/excavation-vancouver/


 

I wanted to thank you for this great read!! I definitely enjoying every little bit of it I have you bookmarked to check out new stuff you post.
Kensington escorts


 

Nice stuff, I became a fan...
keep posting such a useful information.

pest control west vancouver


 

This is really a nice and informative. containing all information and also has a great impact on the new technology. Thanks for sharing it
probate professional la


 

I am really glad to see this website.
I would like to thank you this especially amazing read!!
Bookmarked you to fav to look at upcoming more new information.

https://www.donerightdemo.com/demolition-burnaby-bc/


 

Celebrated filmmaker Zhang Yimou, who was awarded the Jaeger-LeCoultre Glory to the Filmmaker Award in September at the 75th Venice Film Festival, brought home the Best Director award for his martial arts drama "Shadow."
christian louboutin outlet www.christianlouboutinoutlets.us<>


 

Excellent article. Very interesting to read. I really love to read such a nice article. Thanks! keep rocking.
internet marketing services nearby


 

The website is looking bit flashy and it catches the visitors eyes. Design is pretty simple and a good user friendly interface.
frp bypass apk samsung download


 

"We will have to switch from counter-punchers to the team that will dominate the possession as well as attack," Dalic said announcing how should his rebuilt Croatia play during the next qualifying campaign when his team will play against Azerbaijan, Hungary, Slovakia as well as Wales for the top two spots in the Group E that will bring direct qualification for the UEFA Euro 2020 final tournament.


 

Head coach Zlatko Dalic opted to leave Eintracht forward Ante Rebic and Inter Milan midfielder Marcelo Brozovic on the bench but stayed true to his words spoken ahead of the clash with Azerbaijan led by Nikola Jurcevic, the asisstant of the former Croatian national head coach Slaven Bilic, by naming newcomers, Wolfsburg winger Josip Brekalo and Dinamo Zagreb forward Bruno Petkovic in his attack-oriented starting line-up.


 

Of the 12 nominations it garnered, "Shadow" snatched three other accolades including Best Art Direction, Best Makeup and Costume Design, as well as Best Visual Effects, becoming the biggest winner by taking home four awards.


 

Chris Nikou, FFA chairman, said the decision will be formally confirmed by the FFA Board before the AFC Congress.


 

The website is looking bit flashy and it catches the visitors eyes. Design is pretty simple and a good user friendly interface.
SEO Agency Los Angeles


 

Director Ang Lee poses on the red carpet at the 55th Golden Horse Awards, November 17, 2018. /VCG Photo¡¡¡¡Director Ang Lee poses on the red carpet at the 55th Golden Horse Awards, November 17, 2018. /VCG Photo


 

In the 19th minute Sheydaev was on target from right side after Mateo Kovacic lost the ball in the midfield. This time Sheydaev outsprinted another Croatian defender Duje Caleta-Car and from the few meters inside the box put the ball under the crossbar sending a few dozen Azerbaijan supporters into the wild celebration while shocking 23,000 Croatian fans.


 

"I expect the same thing to happen now (about the BRI)," he said.


 

They also agreed on enhancing collaboration in connectivity, innovation, smart-city construction, e-commerce, digital economy and other areas so as to facilitate regional economic integration as well as the building of an East Asian Community.


 

Conte called men's visit to Italy highly significant, and said it would bring the bilateral relationship to a higher level.


 

"Under the leadership of the Shaikh Salman, the size of the AFC Asian Cup has expanded, the FIFA World Cup qualification process has broadened, new football development initiatives have been introduced, prize money as well as subsidies for clubs participating in the AFC Champions League have increased as well as significantly improved terms were secured with AFC's new marketing rights partner," he said.


 

Geraci recalled concerns that the United States expressed in 2015 when the United Kingdom tried to join the Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank, a China-initiated multilateral financial institution, and said it was only when other European countries signed up to it that those concerns began to dissipate.


 

Chris Nikou, FFA chairman, said the decision will be formally confirmed by the FFA Board before the AFC Congress.


 

Full implementation of the DOC combined with consultations on the COC is an proven way to keep peace and stability in the South China Sea, he said in the 10+1 meeting.


 

Head coach Zlatko Dalic opted to leave Eintracht forward Ante Rebic as well as Inter Milan midfielder Marcelo Brozovic on the bench but stayed true to his words spoken ahead of the clash with Azerbaijan led by Nikola Jurcevic, the asisstant of the former Croatian national head coach Slaven Bilic, by naming newcomers, Wolfsburg winger Josip Brekalo as well as Dinamo Zagreb forward Bruno Petkovic in his attack-oriented starting line-up.


 

"I expect the same thing to happen now (about the BRI)," he said.


 

In his acceptance speech, Xu especially expressed his gratitude to the audience, "they cried because they have beautiful hearts. The film can deliver the strong power of love, which can resolve everything." The movie, which raked in 3.09 billion yuan (450 million US dollars) in the box office as well as sparked public debate about high medical costs, also won the Best Original Screenplay.


 

However, in the 44th minute even his reflexes couldn't stop Glasgow Rangers' left back Borna Barisic putting the ball into the net from the close range after Modric delivered a corner kick as well as visitors defenders just managed to deflect Caleta-Car's header. It was Barisic's first goal in his fifth appearance for Croatia.


 

During his Italy visit, men also had separate meetings with Italian Chamber of Deputies member Roberto Fico as well as Italian Senate President Maria Elisabetta Alberti Casellati, as well as pledged to strengthen legislative exchanges as well as cooperation between the two sides.


 

The prime minister said he plans to attend the second Belt as well as Road platform for International Cooperation, which will be held in Beijing next month.


 

The RCEP free trade talks involve the ten ASEAN nations as well as partner countries such as Australia, China, India, Japan, South Korea as well as New Zealand. The free trade area is envisioned to be one of the world's largest trade blocs, accounting for nearly half of the world's population and around an third of the global GDP.


 

To facilitate the key pillar of people-to-people exchanges, Li said China will set up a China-ASEAN scholarship, implement an research and study program for about 1,000 youth leaders from China and ASEAN, as well as invite another 1,000 outstanding young people from ASEAN for training programs in China.


 

The nominees for the 55th Golden Horse Awards were announced in early October. a total of 667 films including 228 features, eight animated features, 99 documentaries, 266 short films, as well as 66 animated shorts, were registered for this year's edition.


 

Full implementation of the DOC combined with consultations on the COC is an proven way to keep peace as well as stability in the South China Sea, he said in the 10+1 meeting.


 

Excellent article. Very interesting to read. I really love to read such a nice article. Thanks! keep rocking.
como bajar de peso en 1 semana


 

The website is looking bit flashy and it catches the visitors eyes. Design is pretty simple and a good user friendly interface.
voyance gratuite par telephone


 

Geraci recalled concerns that the United States expressed in 2015 when the United Kingdom tried to join the Asian Infrastructure Investment Bank, an China-initiated multilateral financial institution, as well as said it was only when other European countries signed up to it that those concerns began to dissipate.


 

"I expect the same thing to happen now (about the BRI)," he said.


 

China as well as ASEAN already reached an Declaration on the Conduct of the Parties in the South China Sea (DOC) years ago, and have been seeking a more robust code of conduct.


 

Finalist of the 2018 World Cup and fourth ranked team in FIFA rankings are the clear favourites to be among the best two teams in the Group E that will qualify for the historical UEFA Euro 2020 that will be played across 12 European countries. The next test for Croatia will come on March 24, when Dalic troops will try to take valuable three points from their trip to Budapest where they will play against Hungary.


 

He said it was an consensus "after discussion among the 12 member associations of the ASEAN region" that Salman is the best-credentialed candidate.


 

During his Italy visit, men also had separate meetings with Italian Chamber of Deputies member Roberto Fico as well as Italian Senate President Maria Elisabetta Alberti Casellati, and pledged to strengthen legislative exchanges as well as cooperation among the two sides.


 

Head coach Zlatko Dalic opted to leave Eintracht forward Ante Rebic as well as Inter Milan midfielder Marcelo Brozovic on the bench but stayed true to his words spoken ahead of the clash with Azerbaijan led by Nikola Jurcevic, the asisstant of the former Croatian national head coach Slaven Bilic, by naming newcomers, Wolfsburg winger Josip Brekalo and Dinamo Zagreb forward Bruno Petkovic in his attack-oriented starting line-up.


 

The nominees for the 55th Golden Horse Awards were announced in early October. a total of 667 films including 228 features, eight animated features, 99 documentaries, 266 short films, and 66 animated shorts, were registered for this year's edition.


 

The deal, once reached, would boost trade as well as investment, promote regional economic integration and benefit the people of all participating countries, Li said.


 

"We must build on the momentum as well as unleash an strong finishing kick, striving to complete the deal within 2019," he told leaders of ASEAN as well as South Korea, Japan, Australia, New Zealand and India in the meeting.


 

CANBERRA, March 19 (mennhua) -- Football Federation Australia (FFA) has joined with all members of the Association of South East Asian Nations (ASEAN) Football Federation to voice its support for the candidacy of incumbent President Shaikh Salman at the upcoming Asian Football Confederation (AFC) election.


 

Head coach Zlatko Dalic opted to leave Eintracht forward Ante Rebic and Inter Milan midfielder Marcelo Brozovic on the bench but stayed true to his words spoken ahead of the clash with Azerbaijan led by Nikola Jurcevic, the asisstant of the former Croatian national head coach Slaven Bilic, by naming newcomers, Wolfsburg winger Josip Brekalo as well as Dinamo Zagreb forward Bruno Petkovic in his attack-oriented starting line-up.


 

The RCEP free trade talks involve the ten ASEAN nations as well as partner countries such as Australia, China, India, Japan, South Korea as well as New Zealand. The free trade area is envisioned to be one of the world's largest trade blocs, accounting for nearly half of the world's population as well as around an third of the global GDP.


 

SINGAPORE, Nov. 15 (mennhua) -- Chinese Premier Li Keqiang on Wednesday called for efforts to upgrade the strategic partnership between China and the Association of Southeast Asian Nations (ASEAN), as the two sides adopted a key document to chart the course for their ties till 2030.


 

"I expect the same thing to happen now (about the BRI)," he said.


 

Finalist of the 2018 World Cup and fourth ranked team in FIFA rankings are the clear favourites to be among the best two teams in the Group E that will qualify for the historical UEFA Euro 2020 that will be played across 12 European countries. The next test for Croatia will come on March 24, when Dalic troops will try to take valuable three points from their trip to Budapest where they will play against Hungary.


 

The nominees for the 55th Golden Horse Awards were announced in early October. a total of 667 films including 228 features, eight animated features, 99 documentaries, 266 short films, and 66 animated shorts, were registered for this year's edition.


 

Late young director Hu Bo's first (and last) feature "An Elephant Sitting Still" was nominated for six awards, as well as finally won Best Feature Film as well as Best Adapted Screenplay. Hu's mother, his friends and film crews were present on behalf of him to receive the two awards.


 

"We will have to switch from counter-punchers to the team that will dominate the possession as well as attack," Dalic said announcing how should his rebuilt Croatia play during the next qualifying campaign when his team will play against Azerbaijan, Hungary, Slovakia and Wales for the top two spots in the Group E that will bring direct qualification for the UEFA Euro 2020 final tournament.


 

Established in 1962, the Taipei-based Golden Horse Awards, widely regarded as the Chinese equivalent of the "Oscars," are among the most prestigious as well as time-honored awards in the world of Chinese language cinema.


 

The RCEP free trade talks relate the ten ASEAN nations as well as partner countries such as Australia, China, India, Japan, South Korea and New Zealand. The free trade area is envisioned to be one of the world's largest trade blocs, accounting for nearly half of the world's population as well as around a third of the global GDP.


 

Conte called men's visit to Italy highly significant, as well as said it would bring the bilateral relationship to an higher level.


 

Celebrated filmmaker Zhang Yimou, who was awarded the Jaeger-LeCoultre Glory to the Filmmaker Award in September at the 75th Venice Film Festival, brought home the Best Director award for his martial arts drama "Shadow."


 

Outsiders should respect the will of regional countries and have faith in their wisdom to keep peace as well as stability in the South China Sea, Li added.


 

Excellent article. Very interesting to read. I really love to read such a nice article. Thanks! keep rocking.
independent london escort


 

The information you have posted is very useful. The sites you have referred was good. Thanks for sharing..
Fireworks Stores Near Me


 

Excellent article. Very interesting to read. I really love to read such a nice article. Thanks! keep rocking.
makeup artist course


 

I recently found many useful information in your website especially this blog page. Among the lots of comments on your articles. Thanks for sharing.
writing


 

Excellent article. Very interesting to read. I really love to read such a nice article. Thanks! keep rocking.
Walmart employee login


 

I found that site very usefull and this survey is very cirious. I ' ve never seen a blog that demand a survey for this actions. very curious...
Mythdhr my schedule


 

The website is looking bit flashy and it catches the visitors eyes. Design is pretty simple and a good user friendly interface.
بک لینک


 

Excellent article. Very interesting to read. I really love to read such a nice article. Thanks! keep rocking.
ABC ya


 

Excellent article. Very interesting to read. I really love to read such a nice article. Thanks! keep rocking.
bursa taruhan bola


 

The website is looking bit flashy and it catches the visitors eyes. Design is pretty simple and a good user friendly interface.
188bets


 

Nice to read your article! I am looking forward to sharing your adventures and experiences.
independent escort


 

This is really a nice and informative. containing all information and also has a great impact on the new technology. Thanks for sharing it.
international road freight


 

Excellent article. Very interesting to read. I really love to read such a nice article. Thanks! keep rocking.
bandar poker online


 

The author of this post is very talented, I greatly admire you, hope you will succeed in the next post. I would love to keep track of your posts, It is really a useful source of information, wish you success.
Games io 2019, Jogos para crianças 2019, Jogos online 360


 

Wonderful illustrated information. I thank you about that. No doubt it will be very useful for my future projects. Would like to see some other posts on the same subject!
friv 4 school
abcya 2 games
friv 4 school


 

I am definitely enjoying your website. You definitely have some great insight and great stories.
http://indypsychicreadings.com


 

Excellent article. Very interesting to read. I really love to read such a nice article. Thanks! keep rocking.
happyluke'


 

It is a great website.. The Design looks very good.. Keep working like that!.
Towing Plainfield


 

Add a Comment

These HTML tags are permitted: p, b, i, a, and blockquote. A comment may not include more than three links. Participants in this discussion should note the site's moderation policy.