Justin Long and John Hodgman as Mac Dude and PC Guy

A few years ago, in one of Apple's last big marketing campaigns while Steve Jobs was alive, the company mocked Microsoft by having Justin Long portray a Mac and John Hodgman a PC in TV commercials. Long's comfortably scruffy dude in sneakers was supposed to be cool, while Hodgman's pudgy businessman was supposed to be a dork who couldn't quite catch up to the times.

I wrote in 2007 that the commercials were doing something for Microsoft it couldn't do for itself -- make the company lovable.

The Mac hipster played by Justin Long is insufferably smug compared to his problem-plagued comic foil, who ends up looking like a well-intentioned underdog unruffled by adversity. He's like Charlie Brown, falling over and over for Lucy's promise to let him kick the football. ... When I spot one of those commercials as I'm blipping through Tivo, I stop to see how Hodgman fares.

As my link shows, Hodgman wasn't rooting for himself either. The Daily Show contributor called his character "delusional" for believing he was cooler than a Mac.

In a piece for The Guardian about his new non-fiction book The Kraus Project, the author Jonathan Franzen reveals himself to be another person who hated Mac Dude:

Any chance that I might have switched to Apple was negated by the famous and long-running series of Apple ads aimed at persuading people like me to switch. The argument was eminently reasonable, but it was delivered by a personified Mac (played by the actor Justin Long) of such insufferable smugness that he made the miseries of Windows attractive by comparison. You wouldn't want to read a novel about the Mac: what would there be to say except that everything is groovy? Characters in novels need to have actual desires; and the character in the Apple ads who had desires was the PC, played by John Hodgman. His attempts to defend himself and to pass himself off as cool were funny, and he suffered, like a human being. (There were local versions of the ad around the world, with comedians David Mitchell and Robert Webb as the PC and Mac in the UK).

-- Rogers Cadenhead

Comments

Any publicity is good publicity, and those ads were more about the PC than they were about the Mac.

Plus, the message that "if you go Mac, you can be one of the cool kids" runs counter to some pretty strongly held moral principles (at least people like to think that they aren't slaves to fashion). On the flip side, beating up on the nerd has become deprecated as geekiness becomes more fashionable.


 

That ad campaign was one I found of great interest during the years it was running. I didn't understand how the public could look at Justin Long in those spots and not see "overwhelmingly smug" as his character's primary characteristic.

Unlike Franzen I did buy a Mac in that period. It's a really nice machine, but I'm still working primarily in Windows.


 

The point of the campaign wasn't to make the Mac look loveable, it was to make the PC look feckless.

The "insufferable hipster" stereotype was already one people associated with Mac users. Running away from that would have made Apple look defensive at a time they wanted to be on the attack, so instead they embraced it in a way that everyone looking at the ad could identify which of the two actors was the Mac before they opened their mouths.

On the other hand, "nice, even huggable, but clueless" was a completely novel and unusual way to portray Microsoft, which was still seen by most as the ten thousand tonne fire-breathing dragon of the computer industry: huge beyond imagination, invulnerable, inevitable and above all else ruthless. The Mac vs PC ads were aimed squarely at defanging Microsoft.

I made a related point at the time: the archetype is lifted straight from Roadrunner vs Coyote: fishbowl.pastiche.org


 

The Roadrunner vs. Coyote comparison is great, but some of the comments to your blog post demonstrate what Franzen is talking about in his essay, particularly this one:

"I think the ascribing of the 'arrogant' trait to Justin Long's character is more about the fact that any Mac user I know (and I have been one since '85) has always known that he/she has access to a superior tool and it is impossible not to just pity the typical PC user a little bit as they struggle so valiantly either with their computer's shortcomings or in trying to justify why they really have the better tool. ... It is impossible not to be a bit arrogant and be a Mac user. Just can't be done."

The mere ownership of a Mac is treated as sufficient cause for a sense of superiority.

At the time the Long/Hodgman commercials began in 2006, I didn't see Microsoft as the 10-ton dragon of the computer industry any more. It was five years after Windows XP and the new Vista version was laying an egg, Mozilla Firefox had taken a huge chunk out of Microsoft's browser share and a lot of my work had moved into the browser where the operating system didn't matter that much.

Certainly today, as Microsoft's market share of computing devices is so much smaller because Apple iPhone and Android are kicking its butt in mobile, Apple couldn't portray Microsoft as a monster that needed to be defanged.


 

Wow, I actually had to bookmark a site! this is a first. Keep it up. brain games for kids


 

I am also writing to make you know what a magnificent encounter my cousin's child developed reading through your site. She even learned several details, which included what it's like to possess an amazing helping nature to have a number of people just comprehend specific complicated matters. You actually did more than my desires. Thanks for showing the useful, safe, informative and as well as unique tips about your topic to Gloria.
red bottom shoes www.redbottom-shoes.us.com<>


 

I simply wanted to write a simple message to express gratitude to you for all the stunning tips and hints you are posting on this site. My extensive internet search has at the end of the day been recognized with extremely good concept to go over with my family members. I would mention that many of us readers are quite fortunate to live in a fabulous site with very many lovely individuals with useful suggestions. I feel extremely happy to have seen your web page and look forward to many more exciting times reading here. Thanks a lot again for a lot of things.
yeezy shoes www.yeezy-shoes.org.uk<>


 

I as well as my guys were found to be reviewing the great tips and hints found on your web blog and instantly I had a terrible suspicion I never thanked the blog owner for those techniques. These people became consequently joyful to learn all of them and have now pretty much been taking pleasure in those things. I appreciate you for being well thoughtful and then for utilizing these kinds of useful areas most people are really desirous to understand about. My very own honest apologies for not expressing gratitude to you sooner.
goyard handbags www.goyard.us.com<>


 

Girls pooping Scathunter is a New Premium Scat Videos website.Check out the Hottest girls with the nicest butts spreading there big asses and shitting into my mouth. Watch as I chew and swallow there loads of scat and cum hard! Do you want scat videos with big butts? Ebony scat sluts? White Girl scat? Or ethnic scat? We have tons of featured scat girls pooping into my mouth sucking dick and eating cum! Watch as these hot bitches pull open there large butt cheeks and shit into my mouth and then suck my dick and I cum hard all over the big asses. The number one big booty scat site is Scathunter.com


 

I together with my guys were found to be going through the great items on your website while then developed a terrible suspicion I had not thanked the website owner for those strategies. The guys became absolutely stimulated to study them and now have in truth been loving these things. Many thanks for getting really thoughtful and for getting certain very good areas millions of individuals are really desperate to learn about. My personal sincere apologies for not saying thanks to you earlier.
caterpillar shoes www.caterpillarboots.us.com<>


 

I simply needed to say thanks once more. I'm not certain what I could possibly have taken care of without the type of concepts provided by you on my question. It was before a real hard dilemma for me personally, however , being able to see this specialised strategy you treated the issue forced me to leap with gladness. Extremely happy for your work and as well , trust you are aware of a great job you're accomplishing educating the mediocre ones all through your websites. Most likely you've never come across any of us.
michael kors handbags www.outletonline-michaelkors.us.org<>


 

I have to express thanks to the writer just for bailing me out of such a predicament. After searching through the the web and meeting tricks which were not productive, I thought my entire life was over. Living devoid of the approaches to the difficulties you've resolved as a result of your blog post is a critical case, and the ones that would have in a wrong way damaged my career if I had not encountered your site. That mastery and kindness in handling all the details was vital. I don't know what I would've done if I hadn't come upon such a subject like this. It's possible to at this point look ahead to my future. Thanks for your time very much for the professional and effective help. I won't hesitate to recommend your web sites to anybody who should have tips on this issue.
jordan retro www.jordan-retro.us.com<>


 

I wanted to compose a brief word to be able to express gratitude to you for the unique techniques you are placing at this site. My time consuming internet lookup has now been compensated with excellent ideas to share with my pals. I would point out that we visitors actually are truly fortunate to dwell in a decent site with so many special professionals with helpful ideas. I feel rather blessed to have discovered your weblog and look forward to so many more enjoyable minutes reading here. Thank you once more for all the details.
yeezy boost 350 v2 www.yeezyboost.com.co<>


 

Sex Story Top Quality Hand Shaking magazine for best source of free online Indian sexy stories daily of hot girls, bhabhi and aunties. Daily new new hot sexy....


 

windshield replacement Aztek Auto Glass Replacement Austin It Is Just One Call Away (512) 563-3335 & Our Austin TX Auto Glass Replacement Crew Its On Your Way With Cheap Auto Glass Windshield Replacement Austin Texas You Can Afford.


 

hotels www.Hotels.Tube has officially launched its website allowing users to create and post videos of hotels and accommodation from around the world. The brand-new start-up company was established to give travellers a more realistic and unbiased look at hotels. www.Hotels.Tube posts videos created by travellers, bloggers, and from their own in-house producers. Each video allows the hotel to be showcased in a more natural way than through many of the promotional clips and advertisements released to the public.


 

https://xn--ntr-1n9d76v795i.com/?p=8853 Kuzirux's popular erotic comic book, the latest work information of the [Ballad of the singer] series! I'd like to read "Ballad 7th episode of the singer soon!" People also say, "What sort of erotic cartoon of a singer?" People made by Mr. Kujirax [Singer's ballad seventh episode singer is disliked] Information and download method will be written this time so check it out!.


 

This is a great inspiring article.I am pretty much pleased with your good work free gift code generator and free gift card generator and free gift card generator


 

Add a Comment

These HTML tags are permitted: p, b, i, a, and blockquote. A comment may not include more than three links. Participants in this discussion should note the site's moderation policy.