Justin Long and John Hodgman as Mac Dude and PC Guy

A few years ago, in one of Apple's last big marketing campaigns while Steve Jobs was alive, the company mocked Microsoft by having Justin Long portray a Mac and John Hodgman a PC in TV commercials. Long's comfortably scruffy dude in sneakers was supposed to be cool, while Hodgman's pudgy businessman was supposed to be a dork who couldn't quite catch up to the times.

I wrote in 2007 that the commercials were doing something for Microsoft it couldn't do for itself -- make the company lovable.

The Mac hipster played by Justin Long is insufferably smug compared to his problem-plagued comic foil, who ends up looking like a well-intentioned underdog unruffled by adversity. He's like Charlie Brown, falling over and over for Lucy's promise to let him kick the football. ... When I spot one of those commercials as I'm blipping through Tivo, I stop to see how Hodgman fares.

As my link shows, Hodgman wasn't rooting for himself either. The Daily Show contributor called his character "delusional" for believing he was cooler than a Mac.

In a piece for The Guardian about his new non-fiction book The Kraus Project, the author Jonathan Franzen reveals himself to be another person who hated Mac Dude:

Any chance that I might have switched to Apple was negated by the famous and long-running series of Apple ads aimed at persuading people like me to switch. The argument was eminently reasonable, but it was delivered by a personified Mac (played by the actor Justin Long) of such insufferable smugness that he made the miseries of Windows attractive by comparison. You wouldn't want to read a novel about the Mac: what would there be to say except that everything is groovy? Characters in novels need to have actual desires; and the character in the Apple ads who had desires was the PC, played by John Hodgman. His attempts to defend himself and to pass himself off as cool were funny, and he suffered, like a human being. (There were local versions of the ad around the world, with comedians David Mitchell and Robert Webb as the PC and Mac in the UK).

-- Rogers Cadenhead

Comments

Any publicity is good publicity, and those ads were more about the PC than they were about the Mac.

Plus, the message that "if you go Mac, you can be one of the cool kids" runs counter to some pretty strongly held moral principles (at least people like to think that they aren't slaves to fashion). On the flip side, beating up on the nerd has become deprecated as geekiness becomes more fashionable.


 

That ad campaign was one I found of great interest during the years it was running. I didn't understand how the public could look at Justin Long in those spots and not see "overwhelmingly smug" as his character's primary characteristic.

Unlike Franzen I did buy a Mac in that period. It's a really nice machine, but I'm still working primarily in Windows.


 

The point of the campaign wasn't to make the Mac look loveable, it was to make the PC look feckless.

The "insufferable hipster" stereotype was already one people associated with Mac users. Running away from that would have made Apple look defensive at a time they wanted to be on the attack, so instead they embraced it in a way that everyone looking at the ad could identify which of the two actors was the Mac before they opened their mouths.

On the other hand, "nice, even huggable, but clueless" was a completely novel and unusual way to portray Microsoft, which was still seen by most as the ten thousand tonne fire-breathing dragon of the computer industry: huge beyond imagination, invulnerable, inevitable and above all else ruthless. The Mac vs PC ads were aimed squarely at defanging Microsoft.

I made a related point at the time: the archetype is lifted straight from Roadrunner vs Coyote: fishbowl.pastiche.org


 

The Roadrunner vs. Coyote comparison is great, but some of the comments to your blog post demonstrate what Franzen is talking about in his essay, particularly this one:

"I think the ascribing of the 'arrogant' trait to Justin Long's character is more about the fact that any Mac user I know (and I have been one since '85) has always known that he/she has access to a superior tool and it is impossible not to just pity the typical PC user a little bit as they struggle so valiantly either with their computer's shortcomings or in trying to justify why they really have the better tool. ... It is impossible not to be a bit arrogant and be a Mac user. Just can't be done."

The mere ownership of a Mac is treated as sufficient cause for a sense of superiority.

At the time the Long/Hodgman commercials began in 2006, I didn't see Microsoft as the 10-ton dragon of the computer industry any more. It was five years after Windows XP and the new Vista version was laying an egg, Mozilla Firefox had taken a huge chunk out of Microsoft's browser share and a lot of my work had moved into the browser where the operating system didn't matter that much.

Certainly today, as Microsoft's market share of computing devices is so much smaller because Apple iPhone and Android are kicking its butt in mobile, Apple couldn't portray Microsoft as a monster that needed to be defanged.


 

You've got one of the better websites.
fotbollstr?jor www.afterglowvp.com


 

Great looking site. Presume you did a bunch of your very own coding.
fotballdrakter barn www.travelstobhutan.com


 

I enjoy this site - its so usefull and helpfull.
fodboldtr?jer med tryk www.crimsontee.com


 

Great looking website. Presume you did a bunch of your own html coding.
magliette calcio a poco prezzo www.synchronizationofus.com


 

Rather instructive, looking onward to coming back.


 

You've impressive information on this website.
billige fotballdrakter www.nottheitgirls.com


 

Maintain the outstanding work !! Lovin' it!


 

I like checking your websites. Cheers!
billige fodboldtr?jer www.zamanthajoeh.com


 

You've gotten possibly the best online websites.
magliette calcio www.doralcentermall.com


 

Thanks for supplying this type of superb details.


 

Truly, this is a invaluable websites.
Maglie Calcio a poco prezzo www.niveauradio.com


 

I visited many blogs however the audio feature for audio songs present at this website is truly marvelous.
mink lashes https://medium.com/@boydweelsabphi1971/why-are-mink-lashes-better-than-routine-false-lashes-f185618418aa


 

Nice Site, Stick to the great work. Many thanks.|


 

Wow, stunning website. Thnx ...
Maglia Bayer Leverkusen Poco Prezzo www.theconservatarianreview.com


 

Great website! It looks very good! Keep up the good work!
Juventus Tr?jer www.shannonmdrealty.com


 

Great looking site. Presume you did a bunch of your own coding.
Fotbollstr?jor www.fashionradicalsnews.com<>


 

You've got amazing info at this point.


 

Great internet site! It looks very professional! Sustain the great job!
fotbolldrakter www.mydescubrimientos.com<>


 

Basically wished to say I am delighted I happened upon your web page!|


 

I delight in the data on your internet site. Much thanks.
Maglia Barcellona Poco Prezzo www.zeropartypolitics.com


 

I was able to find good info from your articles.


 

Quality articles or reviews is the important to interest the visitors to visit the website, that's what this site is providing.
Jocelyn Schueth www.adminbbs.net


 

good night
good morning
happy birthday
good night
good night
good night
good night
good night
good night
good night
good night
good night
good night
good night
good night
good night
good night
good night
good night
good night
good night
good night
good night
good night
good night
good night
good night
good night
good night
good night
good night
good night
good night
good night
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
good morning
Good night Messages
Good night Messages
Good night Messages
Good night Messages
Good night Messages
Good night Messages
Good night Messages
Good night Messages
Good night Messages
Good night Messages
Good night Messages
Good night quotes
Good night quotes
Good night quotes
Good night quotes
Good night quotes
Good night quotes
Good night quotes
Good night quotes
Good night quotes
Good night quotes
Good night quotes
Good night quotes
Good night quotes
Good night quotes
Good night wishes
Good night wishes
Good night wishes
Good night wishes
Good night wishes
Good night wishes
Good night wishes
Good night wishes
Good night wishes
Good night wishes
Good night wishes
Good night wishes
Good night wishes
Good night wishes
Good night wishes
Good night wishes
Good night wishes
Good night wishes
Good night wishes
Good night wishes
Good night wishes
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari/a>
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
best whatsapp status
best whatsapp status
best whatsapp status
best whatsapp status
best whatsapp status
best whatsapp status
best whatsapp status
best whatsapp status
best whatsapp status
best whatsapp status
best whatsapp status
best whatsapp status
best whatsapp status
best whatsapp status
best whatsapp status
Diwali Messages
Diwali Messages
Diwali Messages
Diwali Messages
Diwali Messages
Diwali Messages
Diwali Messages
Diwali Messages
Diwali Messages
Diwali Messages
Diwali Messages
Diwali Messages
Diwali Messages
Diwali Messages
Diwali Messages
good night messages for girlfriend
good night messages for girlfriend
good night messages for girlfriend
good night messages for girlfriend
good night messages for girlfriend
good night messages for girlfriend
good night messages for girlfriend
good night messages for girlfriend
good night messages for girlfriend
good night messages for girlfriend
good night messages for girlfriend
good night messages for girlfriend
good night messages for girlfriend
good night messages for girlfriend
good night messages for girlfriend
good night messages for girlfriend
good night messages for girlfriend
Night Text Messages For Her
Night Text Messages For Her
Night Text Messages For Her
Night Text Messages For Her
Night Text Messages For Her
Night Text Messages For Her

Good Night Girlfriend Collection
Good Night Girlfriend Collection
Good Night Girlfriend Collection
Good Night Girlfriend Collection
Good Night Girlfriend Collection
Good Night Girlfriend Collection
Good Night Girlfriend Collection
Good Night Girlfriend Collection
Good Night Girlfriend Collection
Good Night Girlfriend Collection
Good Night Girlfriend Collection
Good Night Girlfriend Collection
Good Night Girlfriend Collection
Good Night Girlfriend Collection
Good Night Girlfriend Collection
Good Night Messages For Her
Good Night Messages For Her
Good Night Messages For Her
Good Night Messages For Her
Good Night Messages For Her
Good Night Messages For Her
Good Night Messages For Her
Good Night Messages For Her
Good Night Messages For Her
Good Night Messages For Her
Good Night Messages For Her
Good Night Messages For Her
Good Night Messages For Her
Good Night Messages For Her
Good Night Messages For Her
Good Night Messages For Her
Whatsapp Status | Romantic And Sad
Whatsapp Status | Romantic And Sad
Whatsapp Status | Romantic And Sad
Whatsapp Status | Romantic And Sad
Whatsapp Status | Romantic And Sad
Whatsapp Status | Romantic And Sad
Whatsapp Status | Romantic And Sad
Whatsapp Status | Romantic And Sad
Whatsapp Status | Romantic And Sad
Whatsapp Status | Romantic And Sad
Whatsapp Status | Romantic And Sad
Whatsapp Status | Romantic And Sad
Whatsapp Status | Romantic And Sad
Whatsapp Status | Romantic And Sad
Whatsapp Status | Romantic And Sad
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari
Love Shayari

Very usefull article thanks ... keep writing such articles :)
I'm so happy bcoz you are write this post for everyone thnxx a lot

Good night messages for girlfriend

Good Morning messages for girlfriend

Good night love SMS | Romantic Night SMS

Rohit sharma Accountant | Blogger

Good Night Messages For Her

Girlfriend Impress Images and Wallpapaer

I love u messages for girlfriend

Good Night Messages for mother

Good Night Images HD Wallpaper

Happy Diwali Wishes For Girlfriend

Diwali Wishes 2018

Good night messages wishes and quotes

Raksha Bandhan Wishes For Sister *Raksha Bandhan Wishes*

#50 Sweet Good Night Messages For Wife: Romantic Night Quotes For Wife

#50 *Girlfriend Propose Messages* Heart Touching

Good Morning Messages For Wife

Good Morning Messages For Friends

Happy New Year Wishes 2019: Best New Year Messages

I love u Messages for wife

i love u messages for dad

i love u messages for son

i love u messages for mother

good night messages for uncle and aunt

good night images for girlfriend

good night images for whatsapp and facebook

good night quotes messages , wishes, for husband

Good Morning Messages For Friends

Raksha Bandhan Images Brother and Sister

Love Shayari -Love Romantic Shayari

Best Whatsapp Status

Love Attitude Status For Girls & Boys


 

Great looking web site. Think you did a great deal of your very own html coding. sites:ggglese.com
maglie calcio hesportuss.top


 

I wanted to compose you a very small remark just to say thanks a lot once again just for the superb information you have provided on this page. This is really tremendously open-handed of you to deliver publicly precisely what numerous people could have offered for an electronic book to end up making some cash on their own, even more so now that you might well have tried it in the event you considered necessary. Those good tips additionally served as a easy way to be aware that someone else have a similar passion much like my very own to know a whole lot more when it comes to this condition. I believe there are some more fun instances ahead for people who examine your website.
nmd www.adidas-nmds.us.com<>


 

I simply desired to thank you so much all over again. I am not sure the things that I might have used in the absence of these solutions shown by you over my area of interest. It had become a real frightful case in my circumstances, but spending time with the expert approach you treated it made me to jump over gladness. I will be grateful for this guidance and then wish you are aware of an amazing job that you are getting into training people through the use of your web blog. I know that you've never come across any of us.
golden goose sneakers www.goldengoose.us.com<>


 

Thanks for all of your effort on this website. Kim really likes doing investigations and it's easy to understand why. We hear all regarding the lively ways you offer functional strategies via the web site and recommend response from some others on the issue while our favorite daughter is always starting to learn so much. Have fun with the remaining portion of the new year. Your carrying out a good job.
adidas nmd www.adidas-nmds.us.com<>


 

I wish to express appreciation to this writer for bailing me out of this situation. After exploring through the the net and getting ideas which are not helpful, I assumed my life was well over. Existing without the approaches to the problems you have resolved through this short post is a critical case, and those that could have in a negative way affected my entire career if I hadn't discovered your site. Your actual knowledge and kindness in handling all the details was precious. I don't know what I would have done if I hadn't come upon such a step like this. I can also at this time relish my future. Thanks for your time so much for your specialized and results-oriented help. I will not hesitate to suggest your site to any person who should get direction on this subject.
NMD R1 Runner PK White Grey www.adidas-nmds.us.com


 

Add a Comment

These HTML tags are permitted: p, b, i, a, and blockquote. A comment may not include more than three links. Participants in this discussion should note the site's moderation policy.