Jim Minatel, an acquisitions editor at Wiley for one of my books, believes that Google's plan to turn web-crawling googlebots loose on print libraries is a clear violation of copyright.

I'm not so sure.

If I had a copy of the world's most useful computer book (let's call it Movable Type 3 Bible Desktop Edition), and I made a practice of sending one page of the book to people who asked a question answered by that page, would I be violating Wiley's copyright?

Selective quotation of a book is fair use. Is repeated selective quotation of a book still fair?

There are full-text books on the web under copyright, such as Live Simple by John December. Google did to this book what it wants to do to library books in the real world -- it grabbed copies of all the pages and will search the text in response to a query, presenting the relevant excerpts.

As an armchair copyright lawyer, I can't figure out how it matters that Google grabbed one book with a bot and grabbed the other with a scanner. Google grabs the full text of copyrighted works all the time -- 56,000 on this server alone. If Google Print is illegal, wouldn't Google be illegal as well?

Thank God we have wealthy corporations with high-powered intellectual property lawyers who can answer this question for us.

-- Rogers Cadenhead

Comments

Just look at the above.
The invasion of the spambots is here.
They're all over the place.
We need some spam nukes.

Time to call in the Winerbots.


 

I get all Googley-eyed when I think about issues like this.


 

Hello, good online site you've gotten presently.
Liverpool Tr?jer www.shannonmdrealty.com


 

Maintain the great job and delivering in the group!


 

The knowledge is incredibly exciting.


 

Wow, lovely site. Thnx ...
Maglia Lazio Poco Prezzo www.theconservatarianreview.com


 

thank so much for your website it assists a lot.
Maglia Atletico Madrid Poco Prezzo www.zeropartypolitics.com


 

You have got among the best online websites.
Barcelona Tr?jer www.asleftasfound.com


 

How goes it, very good internet site you have got presently.
Napoli Tr?jor www.bettermensolutions.com


 

Sustain the great work and generating the crowd!


 

Maintain the outstanding job !! Lovin' it!


 

Many thanks extremely helpful. Will share website with my pals.
fotbollskl?der www.afterglowvp.com


 

Sustain the remarkable work !! Lovin' it!


 

Thanks pertaining to furnishing many of these terrific post.


 

Simply wanted to say Now i am lucky I stumbled on the page!|


 

I appreciate checking your site. Thanks for your time!
billige fotballdrakter www.nottheitgirls.com


 

Great looking site. Presume you did a great deal of your very own coding.
fotbollstr?jor www.tampabaygoodliving.com


 

You've fantastic info on this web-site.
magliette calcio www.doralcentermall.com


 

The data is really useful.


 

I treasure the information on your site. Thank you so much.
maglie calcio www.haeroo.com


 

I like this site - its so usefull and helpfull.
Magliette Calcio Poco Prezzo www.wendtsporkpalace.com


 

I enjoy this website - its so usefull and helpfull. sites:ggglese.com
maglie calcio a poco prezzo turizmasistani.com


 

Add a Comment

These HTML tags are permitted: p, b, i, a, and blockquote. A comment may not include more than three links. Participants in this discussion should note the site's moderation policy.